How to Migrate From Circle.so Without Losing Members

A step-by-step plan to migrate from Circle.so: what to inventory, export and rebuild, how to move members and payments, and how to cut over calmly.

By the Hopper team

Coach helping a member access a new community

Migrating from Circle.so is a project of about two weeks, and it goes well when you do three things in order: take inventory of what you run, move members and payments with their access intact, and keep Circle readable until the new home is tested. Do it that way and your members barely notice the move. They just find a better place to land. If you want someone to carry the heavy parts, we do the client migration and payment migration for you at Hopper, free, with founder-led onboarding.

This guide is for coaches, healers and educators who already have paying members and have decided Circle no longer fits, whether the reason is cost, transaction fees, or the feeling of running a community in one tool, courses in another and checkout in a third.

TL;DR

  • Inventory first: spaces, courses, events, paid tiers, automations, integrations and your member list. Decide what moves, what gets rebuilt and what retires.
  • Export members, payments and content before you cancel, and open every file to check it is complete.
  • Payments are the risky step. Subscriptions can lose their original billing dates in a re-import, so test with a small batch first.
  • Build and test the new space as a member would, soft launch with a small group, then announce a single cutover date.
  • On Hopper, migration and onboarding are free, and one plan covers unlimited hubs, members, team and products.

Table of Contents

Before you move anything: take inventory

Most failed migrations fail on a surprise, not on a hard step. A surprise is usually something you forgot you were running. Spend an hour with a blank document and list everything your Circle community does today.

Walk through it like a member would:

  • Spaces and groups. How many are there, which are paid, which are free, and which are dead? Moving is the best moment to retire a space nobody has posted in for six months.
  • Courses and lessons. Note the format of each: video, audio, text, downloads, quizzes. Keep the original video files somewhere you own.
  • Events and live replays. Recurring calls, workshops and the recordings attached to them.
  • Paid access. Every paywall, tier, bundle and coupon, and how many active subscribers sit on each.
  • Automations and integrations. Welcome emails, tagging rules, Zapier links, email-marketing syncs, anything that fires when a member joins.
  • Your member list. Names, emails, join dates, tags and the access each person has.

Next to each line, write one word: move, rebuild or retire. That single column becomes your project plan.

Then decide what you want the new home to be. If the honest answer is "the same thing, but cheaper", you will recreate what you have. If it is "one place where people join, learn, talk and buy", this is your chance to design that. In Hopper, a hub is a self-contained space for one business or programme, so many coaches use the migration to split a crowded Circle community into clean hubs. One account runs unlimited hubs on one plan.

What to export, and what you will likely rebuild

The general rule for any community platform move: structured data exports cleanly, and anything that depends on the platform's own logic gets rebuilt.

Usually exports as files:

  • Your member list, with names, emails and join dates
  • Tags and profile fields
  • Payment and subscription records
  • Your own uploaded media, if you kept the originals

Usually gets rebuilt or recreated:

  • Space structure and settings
  • Automations and workflows
  • Event schedules and recurring calls
  • Badges, leaderboards and other gamification
  • Course structure, drip timing and quizzes

Check Circle's own help center for the current export options on your plan, and ask Circle support what they can send for posts and comments, since those are the pieces that rarely come out as a tidy file. Confirm how long your data stays available after you cancel, and keep your plan active until every export is verified.

Verify every file

An export you have not opened is not a backup. Open each file. Count the rows against the member count in your dashboard. Spot-check five people you know, including one on a paid tier and one who joined years ago. Confirm that tags and dates survived. A checklist from a community-data publisher makes the same point: confirm exported files open, and confirm your route into the new platform can reproduce what you had, or the manual work surfaces later at the worst time.

Save everything in a folder with the date in its name. You will refer to it for weeks.

Moving your members so their access carries over

Members care about one thing: that they can get in tomorrow, to the same things they paid for, without a fuss. Everything else is detail.

Here is the sequence that protects access:

  1. Map access before you import. Write down, for every tier, exactly what that person can reach: which course, which space, which replays. Your new platform needs the same map.
  2. Import a small batch first. Ten to twenty people, ideally including a few friendly regulars.
  3. Check each of them as that member. Can they log in? Do they see the right course and the right hub? Does their tag or tier match?
  4. Import the rest only after the small batch looks right.
  5. Send the invite email with one clear button and a plain explanation of what changes and what stays the same.

The common failure is a perfect member list with the wrong access attached. Someone who paid for the full programme lands on a free tier and emails you at 11 p.m. Mapping access first prevents most of that.

On Hopper, the member part is something we take off your hands. Our free migration includes moving your clients across, and our onboarding is led by the founder, so you are not guessing at the mapping alone.

Subscriptions and payments: the step that needs the most care

If you charge for membership, this is the step that decides whether the migration feels smooth or expensive.

A test reported by a membership-platform reviewer shows why. A CSV import between two membership platforms did not carry over the original billing anniversary dates, so every re-imported subscriber started a fresh billing cycle on the day of import. Imagine that happening to 200 members at once. The fix the reviewer recommends is simple: export a small test batch, import it into a sandbox or free-trial account, and check billing dates, tags and access-tier mapping by hand before touching your real list.

Follow that approach for your own move:

  • List every active subscription with its price, billing interval and next renewal date.
  • Decide each one's fate. Keep the same price, grandfather an old rate, or move people to a new offer. Write it down so you treat people consistently.
  • Talk to your payment processor about moving active subscriptions. Saved payment methods often need the customer's consent to be reused somewhere new, so ask what your processor requires before you plan the date.
  • Keep your old billing running until the new one is confirmed for each member. Cancel the old subscription only after the new one is live, never before.
  • Watch the first renewal cycle. Check that the first charges on the new platform land on the right day and the right amount.

Hopper accepts creators in every country Stripe supports, and our free migration includes payment migration as well as client migration, so the billing transfer is a step we handle with you rather than leave to a spreadsheet.

A worked example

Say you run a 90-person membership. Sixty members pay monthly, twenty-five pay annually and five are on a legacy rate. Your inventory shows the annual members renew across eleven different months.

Membership tiers and annual renewal timing

A careless import resets all twenty-five annual members to the import date. Next year they all renew in the same week, and several of them are charged early for a year they have already half used. A careful migration keeps each renewal date, moves the five legacy members with a note, and checks three people from each group before moving the rest. The difference is an afternoon of checking.

Your migration plan, week by week

Here is a realistic schedule for a solo coach or small team. Compress it if your community is small.

WhenWhat you doDone when
Days 1 to 2Inventory; mark each item move, rebuild or retireOne-page plan exists
Days 2 to 4Export members, payments and content; verify every fileFiles open and counts match
Days 3 to 7Build the new hub: spaces, library, landing page, productsYou can walk through it as a member
Days 7 to 9Test the full join flow with a test accountLogin, course access, a post and a purchase all work
Days 9 to 11Soft launch with 10 to 20 engaged membersTheir issues are fixed
Days 11 to 14Announce the date, move everyone, keep Circle read-onlyMembers are active in the new space

A community-migration agency suggests the same rhythm: build and test the whole join flow as a member before announcing, soft launch with a small engaged group, then run both platforms side by side with the old one readable but frozen. The logic holds for any size. Every problem you find with twenty friendly members is one you do not find with two hundred.

Testing, then cutting over

Testing means doing what a new member does, not clicking around as admin. Create a test account and:

  • Join through your real landing page or invite link
  • Open a course and play a video on your phone
  • Post in a thread and react to someone else's
  • Buy something, then check the receipt and the access that follows
  • Confirm any welcome message arrives

Do this on mobile first. Most members will open your community from a phone, and a native app on iOS and Android is part of both Hopper plans, so they get a real app that lives on their home screen instead of a browser tab.

Then pick your cutover date. Keep it simple: announce one date, freeze new posts in Circle on that day, leave Circle readable for a short period, and point everything to the new link. Keep your own tools in sync: update your email signature, social bios, checkout links and any link in a Linktree or Stan Store page that still points to Circle.

Telling members, and looking after the ones who lag

The announcement matters as much as the technology. People tolerate change when they understand why it is happening and what it means for them.

A good announcement answers four questions in the first screen: why you are moving, what improves for them, what they need to do, and by when. Send it three times: when you announce, a week before, and on the day. Then write a personal note to every member who has not logged in within a few days of the cutover. A short, warm message from you beats any automated reminder.

If you teach music, a marketing system for music educators can help you think through how you reach students and families while you switch, and the same principle applies to any teaching business: the people who move last are usually the busiest, not the least loyal, so make the first step tiny.

Problems coaches commonly run into

  • Billing dates reset after an import. Test first, as above.
  • Tags and tiers do not map. A tag in one platform becomes a plain field in another. Decide your tier structure before you import.
  • Automations quietly stop. Welcome emails and drip releases are rebuilt, not imported. Test each one.
  • Old links still point to Circle. Search your website, emails, social posts and bios.
  • Posts and comments feel lost. Decide early whether members need the history. Often the best answer is a curated set of your best threads, republished in the new space, instead of everything.
  • Cancelling too soon. Keep the old plan until exports are verified and the first renewal cycle has run.

What the move can look like on Hopper

If you are leaving Circle partly because of cost, here is what we publish. Hopper Base is $58 per month, or $580 per year. Hopper Pro is $108 per month, or $1,080 per year. Migration and onboarding are free. Both plans include unlimited hubs, members, team and products plus the native iOS and Android app, and Pro adds Async Sessions for asynchronous coaching and 0% fees.

Your community, library of unlimited video, audio and live replays, landing page and checkout live under one roof. Sprout, our built-in AI twin, answers students from your own lessons and escalates the rest to you, which gives you back evenings you would otherwise spend on repeat questions.

Hopper

If you are ready to see it, start with Hopper and tell us you are coming from Circle. We will do the move with you.

Perspective

I built Hopper because I watched coaches spend more time stitching tools together than teaching. One tool for the course, one for the community, one for checkout, one more for the app. Every one of them with its own bill and its own way of breaking.

Leaving a platform is scary because the platforms are built that way. Switching is painful, and for many of them that lock-in is part of the business. We are a bet against it: one flat plan, unlimited hubs, members, team and products, and a native app for your members on both plans.

That is why we do the migration ourselves, for free. Your members are your tribe, not rows in a file. When you move, I want them to arrive somewhere that feels like a digital living room, not a set of stitched tools. The lecture hall is closed. The playground is open.

Cedrik, Founder at Hopper.so

FAQ

How long does it take to migrate from Circle.so?

For a solo coach or small team, plan on about two weeks from inventory to cutover. The export and import are quick. Most of the time goes into mapping access, testing the join flow and giving members notice. Smaller communities can move faster.

Will my members lose access when I switch?

Not if you map each tier's access before importing, test with a small batch and keep the old platform readable until everyone has arrived. On Hopper, our free migration moves your clients across and our onboarding is founder-led, so the mapping is done with you.

What happens to my paying subscribers?

Treat subscriptions as their own project. List every active subscription, ask your payment processor what it requires to move saved payment methods, and check that renewal dates survive. Hopper's free migration includes payment migration alongside client migration.

Do I need to rebuild my courses by hand?

Some of the work is rebuilding, mainly structure, drip timing, quizzes and automations. Keep your original video and audio files, and use the move to tidy lessons you have outgrown. Hopper's library takes unlimited video, audio and live replays, with drip content, quizzes and certificates.

Can I run Circle and a new platform at the same time?

Yes, and it is the safest way to move. Keep Circle read-only while members settle, then close it once the first renewal cycle on the new platform has gone through cleanly.

Sources

On our list and want off? .